Gatsby by Windsor Arms

De reviews over Gatsby by Windsor Arms van mensen die hier hebben gegeten. Gebaseerd op recente beoordeling.

1. CF

   ClintonF vip

   Toronto5 recensies

   5.0

   Gegeten op 15 februari 2020

   1. Algeheel 5
   2. Eten 5
   3. Bediening 5
   4. Sfeer 5

   One word - Amazing!!!
   

   Is dit nuttig?

2. L

   Laurence

   Palm Springs / 1 recensie

   1.0

   Gegeten op 2 maart 2025

   1. Algeheel 1
   2. Eten 3
   3. Bediening 1
   4. Sfeer 4

   The place is really nice and comfortable although why a place called Gatsbys would have an Italian menu? The wait person and apparently bartender were taken a bit by surprise that a gin Martini required dry vermouth - he came to the table to make sure we didn't actually want sweet vermouth before they had to go to the storeroom to see if they actually had any dry vermouth. A long wait later they found some. Then, they had to go in search (back to the storeroom) of the key ingredient for the featured house mocktail. When ordering our food we were asked whether we wanted our carpaccio well done or medium! The food itself was good, but not special. We had to send the soggy French fries back. Overall, at the generous "fine dining" prices, there is really no reason to go there. Sadly, because it's such an iconic building and a really evocative name (but not for an Italian restaurant). It's probably a really nice meeting place for drinks after work. But not for dinner.
   

   Is dit nuttig?

3. H

   Hugh vip

   Montreal2 recensies

   4.0

   Gegeten op 1 maart 2025

   1. Algeheel 4
   2. Eten 4
   3. Bediening 4
   4. Sfeer 4

   Jazz night. I will avoid next time. Served wrong salad.
   

   Is dit nuttig?

4. T

   Tonny

   Toronto1 recensie

   1.0

   Gegeten op 22 februari 2025

   1. Algeheel 1
   2. Eten 1
   3. Bediening 3
   4. Sfeer 1

   The food was not good which was very disappointing given the exorbitant price point. Both lamb rack (medium) and steak striploin (medium rare) were underdone. They were audio testing during our visit and had a lot of feedback screeching on the speakers. Does not compare to other high end restaurants, you should skip.
   

   Is dit nuttig?

5. M

   Marls

   Toronto9 recensies

   2.0

   Gegeten op 15 februari 2025

   1. Algeheel 2
   2. Eten 3
   3. Bediening 1
   4. Sfeer 5

   I will start by saying I don’t believe our experience will be everyone’s experience. I will add the ambiance is great, it is is a beautiful building. The food was plated nicely but for the cost did not taste high quality. We initially had fair seats, the live music wasn’t visible, the manager without prompt asked if we would like to move and placed us in what I believe were the best seats in the restaurant. It is unfortunate that from that point our service was quite poor. We had ordered drinks and had water before we moved seats, our starter and main course both came before water was given (on our request) and our drinks we also had to request again. Next to us was a table that arrived after us and received their drinks and each course far before us, it was quite easy for the waiter to see we had no water, the amount of times he was standing right in front of our table serving another couple. I understand Valentine’s Day is busy, but our dinner was late in the evening and it was more than manageable for the staff I saw present. The issue was mis management and the visible arguments the staff was having. Staff were annoyed while serving us and mentioned they were being “sabotaged” by other staff. I was there to enjoy a relaxing evening, not to be involved in politics of the staff. When our drinks finally came, my partners was very good, she enjoyed it. Mine however had no alcohol. When I complained about the service, a different manger, went to the bar shouted at our intial server before we moved seats, a black woman and not either of the two white males serving our current area. When I walked to him and corrected his mistake he lied to me “I was not shouting at her.” The experience unfortunately was quite bad. I was annoyed that staff was disrespectful to each other in earshot of customers. I was disappointed seeing a table right in front of us getting fair service while our was so poor. I was offered a free drink, declined. I will not be going back.
   

   Is dit nuttig?

6. V

   Vadim

   Toronto1 recensie

   2.0

   Gegeten op 14 februari 2025

   1. Algeheel 2
   2. Eten 1
   3. Bediening 1
   4. Sfeer 4

   We visited Gatsby by Windsor on Valentine’s Day, expecting an exceptional fine dining experience. Ambiance & Service The interior exuded old England grandeur—fabric and leather-adorned walls, intricate ceilings, and elegant chandeliers set a refined tone. However, the service did not match the setting. Our waiter handled cutlery with bare hands instead of providing fresh ones. Our table was unstable and was only fixed when we pointed it out. Another noticeable lapse was the lack of attentiveness—our glasses were never topped up, an oversight at a venue of this caliber. Food Quality The evening started on a high note. Starters were beautifully plated, evoking Michelin-star standards—small portions, but crafted with sophistication. However, the experience declined with the main course. The halibut with potatoes was disappointingly average, lacking depth in flavor, and the raspberry mousse was underwhelming. The most concerning issue arose when we found a hair in our meal. When reported, we expected a sincere apology or a more thoughtful response. Instead, we were merely offered a replacement dish, which we declined. By that point, our appetite was gone. For a fine dining establishment, the handling of such a matter should have been far more professional and considerate. Price & Value The final bill came to $400 for two, including two glasses of wine. An automatic 18% gratuity was added, leaving no choice in tipping. Given the disappointing aspects of the meal and service, this felt unwarranted. Overall Experience & Rating Gatsby by Windsor impresses with its aesthetics, but it falls short in execution. The lack of consistency in food quality and service etiquette prevents it from reaching true fine dining standards.
   

   Is dit nuttig?

7. w

   wayne

   Toronto4 recensies

   3.0

   Gegeten op 14 februari 2025

   1. Algeheel 3
   2. Eten 4
   3. Bediening 2
   4. Sfeer 4

   Lovely olde school restaurant with live music. We felt rushed through and out. Two courses were delivered at same time. Meal order take. With cocktail order. Just wish we could have enjoyed it more.
   

   Is dit nuttig?

8. B

   Brian

   Toronto7 recensies

   5.0

   Gegeten op 13 februari 2025

   1. Algeheel 5
   2. Eten 5
   3. Bediening 5
   4. Sfeer 5

   Classic old style elegance. A pleasure to be surrounded by and cradled with the ambiance. Food was of the highest order. A wonderful evening out.
   

   • 
   • 
   • 

   Is dit nuttig?

9. D

   Dominic

   Toronto3 recensies

   5.0

   Gegeten op 11 februari 2025

   1. Algeheel 5
   2. Eten 5
   3. Bediening 5
   4. Sfeer 5

   Great food and service. The waiter was very attentive to our needs Would recommend this as a romantic evening
   

   Is dit nuttig?

10. H

    Heather

    Toronto1 recensie

    5.0

    Gegeten op 10 februari 2025

    1. Algeheel 5
    2. Eten 5
    3. Bediening 5
    4. Sfeer 5

    An oasis in the heart of Toronto. Excellent ambience, great service and food.
    

    Is dit nuttig?